Blog AnalysisEuropean policy

Women block in European career

(BRUSSELS2) While the debate on women at the head of the European Commission risks being revived if the Member States do not make a small effort (read: There is a lack of women in the future 2014 Commission. A real political problem…), we can also look at the (small) European staff. The report - if it is better than in a number of Member States - is not really encouraging, however, for equality between men and women.

Women... darlings at the bottom of the ladder!

When we look at the detailed personnel statistics of the European Commission, we see that women are all the more cherished when they are at the bottom of the ladder... It is quite clear when you put the figures in a spreadsheet (which we did, with percentage calculation for each category). Women represent 2/3 on average of assistant positions (66%) but are only 2/5th when we look at administrator positions (42%). And still it is about average... The more one goes up in the hierarchy, in each of the categories, the more the feminine power is eroded. And conversely...

A career blocker

At the level of the assistants, it is obvious. While women are clearly in the majority in the various grades - almost 90% in the lower levels up to 75% in the middle levels - from grade 8, when it comes to accessing positions of responsibility, it reverses. And at the top level, there is only barely 1 in 5 women.

Same for administrators. With a less steep profile. Although the distribution is fairly balanced up to level AD9 (another 44%), it decreases rapidly as soon as one moves on to positions of responsibility, reaching barely a quarter at the three higher levels (General Managers or Directors, AD14 to AD16).

There is like a glass ceiling that women cannot cross, quite incomprehensible in view of the speeches displayed. Would women become less competent when they go from AD 8 to AD 12?

Significant wage inequality

This fact leads to glaring wage inequality. An AD8 or an AD9 earns, in fact, between 6300 euros and 8200 euros (*) while an AD13 or AD14 (director level) passes, respectively, the bar of 12.000 or 13.000 euros and a 15 or AD16 happily caps at 17 or 18.000 euros (general manager level). If we rely on the rules put in place by the European Court of Justice, we are faced with a fairly blatant case of violation of equal pay for men and women.

A real problem

At the European Commission, questioned by B2, we are well aware of this problem. Female directors say they want to go into management/leadership positions. But when you look at the balance between men and women in the applications for these positions, very few are women,” explained one of the spokespersons for the European executive. However, the Commission refuses to accept its “defeat”. We “started to examine why women do not apply and took action to address these reasons and encourage more women to apply with different mechanisms (monitoring, early identification and encouragement of talent, etc.).

A well-paid European civil service

Incidentally, we note that nearly 3000 EU civil servants (i.e. a third of the civil service) earn more than 12.000 euros per month (grade AD 13), i.e. a fifth of the European civil service (5000 people if we take the level of AD12), with congestion at levels AD 12 and AD 13. This is notable in times of economic crisis and perhaps also explains the budgetary problems that the European Commission has. Even if wages have been virtually frozen (a fact little known to the general public) since 2010.

(*) basic salary, without bonus

EC men women statistics
grids Total women %
administrators
AD16 35 8 23%
AD15 169 39 23%
AD14 509 121 24%
AD13 2 302 667 29%
AD12 1832 669 37%
AD11 769 299 39%
AD10 1092 448 41%
AD9 978 432 44%
AD8 1145 494 43%
AD7 1459 710 49%
AD6 1510 807 53%
AD5 1527 870 57%
Total 13327 5564 42%
Wizards
That11 147 30 20%
That10 355 92 26%
That9 671 284 42%
That8 716 392 55%
That7 1194 923 77%
That6 1405 1060 75%
That5 1540 965 63%
That4 1329 811 61%
That3 1407 942 67%
That2 700 596 85%
That1 771 649 84%
Total 10235 6744 66%
Figures: European Commission statistical bulletin 1 May 2014
Spreadsheet: B2

Nicolas Gros Verheyde

Chief editor of the B2 site. Graduated in European law from the University of Paris I Pantheon Sorbonne and listener to the 65th session of the IHEDN (Institut des Hautes Etudes de la Défense Nationale. Journalist since 1989, founded B2 - Bruxelles2 in 2008. EU/NATO correspondent in Brussels for Sud-Ouest (previously West-France and France-Soir).

2 thoughts on “Women block in European career"

  • William Belmont

    A relative fall in the highest salaries is clearly necessary. The most effective way is to increase community income tax (because it exists!) and make it much more progressive – from AD 9 or 10, for example. Senior executive salaries are justified for general managers or directors, but certainly not for simple administrators, which is too often the case. Unfortunately, the latest reform has cut almost everywhere except in this huge expenditure item, and the austerity imposed since 2010 affects everyone in the same way, regardless of income level. Perhaps because those who negotiate on the side of the European institutions are themselves at the very top of the ladder?

  • Felix Geradon

    As regards the glass ceiling, the Commission should admit that it is doing everything to maintain it. It demanded and obtained from the Council and the Parliament (who asked for nothing better) that the heads of unit should not be able to benefit from the flexible working hours system. It is a very effective way to maintain strong male supremacy in positions of responsibility.
    As for W. Belmont's observation that the latest reform did not cut this item of expenditure, it is nevertheless clear that, in the future, the highest grades, both for administrators and for assistants , will no longer be accessible to “simple” administrators or assistants.
    Modifying the progressiveness of the tax would be possible, but it is already progressive and the “solidarity levy” (an additional “super-tax” is even more so). Be that as it may, given the absence of tax allowances and exemptions, the actual tax rate for European civil servants is well within the average of the Member States.

Comments closed.

s2Member®